Spinning Plates

Thoughts from the Vinyl Deli founder

6 May 2025

Would I Start Vinyl Deli Today?

I ask myself this question regularly.

Would I start Vinyl Deli today?

It’s been over five and a half years since I took the idea and ran with it. We launched the website and opened orders on 31st October 2019.

I’ve said this before, but I’m incredibly proud of how far we’ve come, and simply the fact that the business still exists is something I’ll always be proud of. I can’t wait to hit 10 years.

But would I start this beautiful thing again if I could?

Honestly, it depends on where I was in life.

The idea for Vinyl Deli has existed for over a decade. As I write this, I’m flicking between Notes on my phone dated back to 2013 — the earliest seeds of what Vinyl Deli would become.

At the time, what I really wanted was to start a record label.

In 2013, though, making money from music as an independent was tough. Funding an album felt impossible without capital. And I had none.

One model I sketched was connecting artists directly with fans, offering a subscription where artists could share the music they loved on vinyl.

The label would handle fulfilment and logistics, taking a small cut to cover costs. Artists would grow their income, grow their audience, and fund their next records.

It’s still a model I rarely see today, but it should exist.

The record label never happened. Fast forward a few years, and frustration had built up in every area of my life.

I was in a relationship where, looking back, I was putting my life on pause to help someone else with their career. I don’t regret it, but it wore me down, and it became the root of most of our arguments.

At the same time, I was stuck in a job that drained me. Working hard, feeling unrewarded, feeling like nothing I made really mattered.

I was desperate for a project where no one else had to approve anything — where I could just make something.

In September 2019, during a work trip in Scotland and another in Detroit, the pressure broke. Life stress. Relationship stress. Work stress.

And finally, the realisation hit: It’s about time I did something for myself.

That night, I spent two hours on Google, sent some emails, and Vinyl Deli was born. When I got home, I built the website and launched in October.

A friend became our first subscriber. And our third subscriber — Abigail and Keith — are still Vinyl Deli members today. (Hi!!)

Now you know why I started it — would I start it today if I were in the same place?

Short answer: No.

Just like I didn’t start the record label back in 2013, I’ve learned that time is money. And while I’m happy with what I’ve built, I’ve subsidised it with my own time, my own wages, working for far less than minimum wage.

(But don’t cry for me. I chose it. And I still choose it.)

Still, I often feel like a busy fool. And maybe I am.

Right now, I’m the bottleneck for both companies I run. It’s hard when you’ve built something around your own taste, your own hands, and now you have to figure out how to scale it beyond yourself.

In 2022, I built systems to lighten the monthly curation and fulfilment workload.

In 2024 and 2025, I’m working on scaling the operations further; building the capabilities we need to evolve, not just survive.

Along the way, through all the bespoke software and tools I’ve built, I’ve realised something: Given how I think, how I solve problems, I probably should have started with software first.

But if I hadn’t lived all this chaos firsthand, would I have known what to fix?

Probably not.

There’s a term in software: “dogfooding” your own product. Living your own problems, solving them for yourself before solving them for others.

That’s exactly what I’ve been doing.

Still, if I’d started with tools that solved the problems I faced at past jobs, I might have built a higher-margin business earlier (50% margins instead of 10%, say) and used that to fund Vinyl Deli properly.

Instead, I’m battling operational complexities, designing better experiences for our members, and keeping the lights on — for the businesses, the team, and myself.

It’s a tough balancing act.

It’s also why I’m now building software that we can soon offer to other businesses — tools tested and used inside Vinyl Deli itself. New income streams to fund the bigger dream.

So, would I still want to build Vinyl Deli given the above?

Yes — but differently.

I would’ve started by building cashflow businesses first. Built the systems. Built the team. Then poured my time and money into building this beautiful, maddening thing properly.

Do I regret the path I’ve taken?

No. (But sometimes my frustration sounds a lot like regret.)

I love what Vinyl Deli is today. And I can’t wait to finally roll out the improvements I’ve had stuck in my head for years.

I really believe it’s going to take the experience and the whole spirit of Vinyl Deli to another level.

Right. Now I need to get back to operating.

Thanks for reading,
Jordan